Indiscretion Of An American Wife (DVD)(2020)

After the relative failures of Duel in the Sun (1946) and The Paradine Case (1947), legendary producer David O. Selznick was seeking a new direction. An avid movie aficionado, he had become interested in the Italian neorealist works of Vittorio De Sica (The Bicycle Thief, Miracle in Milan). A collaboration, however seemingly unlikely, was soon in the works. De Sica conceived of a film set entirely in an Italian train station, with a variety of stories going on at once. The incompatibility between the two cinema legends quickly became apparent when Selznick demanded that his wife, movie star Jennifer Jones, star. De Sica's ideas for side stories faded into the background or were completely jettisoned as the story was reconstructed to focus on a Philadelphia housewife forced to leave her Italian lover behind. Montgomery Clift, hot on the heels of his Academy Award-nominated role in A Place in the Sun (1951) was chosen to co-star. Cast as Jones' adoring nephew was a young Richard Beymer in his first role. He would later play Tony in West Side Story (1961) and Mr. Horne on Twin Peaks (1988-1991). Filming was turbulent as Selznick and De Sica, both used to having final say on their pictures, battled for control. The screenplay by De Sica's usual collaborator Cesare Zavattini was rewritten by both Truman Capote and Carson McCullers at Selznick's request (Capote receives a "Dialogue by" credit, though he later told an interviewer he only worked on two scenes.) De Sica shot in his trademark neorealist style, but Selznick panicked when he realized that there were no closeups of Jones. They compromised by bringing English cinematographer (and frequent John Huston collaborator) Oswald Morris on set to do the requisite Hollywood glamor shots. Ultimately De Sica had a two hour film entitled Terminal Station, which he was allowed to release unadulterated in Italy, while Selznick was free to take the footage back to America to re-edit as he pleased. Removing the last vestiges of De Sica's subplots and adding Morris' lingering closeups of Jones and Clift, the producer emerged with Indiscretion of an American Wife, a picture that more closely resembled a big-budget Hollywood movie. Even then, Selznick ran into trouble with the Production Code Administration, who were concerned with its "improper treatment of adultery." Further edits made it, in Selznick's words, "the most moral picture ever to come out of Europe." The final American version ran only 63 minutes. Indiscretion of an American Wife would receive an Oscar nomination for Christian Dior's costume design at the 27th Annual Academy Awards.